Bahney House Hotel offers affordable, pet- and kid-friendly accommodations with kitchens, WiFi, and a convenient laundry facility. Experience a historic property thoughtfully updated for extended stays, close to local sights and recreation in Myerstown, P
Visitors appreciate the spacious rooms, included amenities, and property improvements, while some raise concerns about management and transient guest presence.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Bahney House Hotel, nestled in the heart of Myerstown, PA, stands as a testament to both history and hospitality. With a solid 4.1-star rating, this longstanding establishment offers a unique blend of comfort, convenience, and local charm. Its location at 2 W Main Ave places visitors within easy reach of regional attractions, making it an ideal base for those keen on sightseeing and recreation.
The hotel’s appeal lies not just in its convenient setting but in its thoughtful amenities. Guests appreciate well-sized rooms equipped with practical features like microwaves, mini-fridges, cable TV, and WiFi, all contributing to a comfortable extended stay. The presence of an on-site laundromat adds to the ease, while plans for an upcoming salon highlight ongoing efforts to enhance guest experience. Not to be overlooked are the pet-friendly and kid-friendly policies, which signal an openness to travelers of all kinds, coupled with a smoke-free environment that ensures a clean and healthy atmosphere.
However, Bahney House Hotel is not without its complexities. Several guests have noted the transient nature of its clientele, reflecting challenges that sometimes accompany older establishments undergoing revitalization. One review highlights a difficult interaction with management, which signals room for growth in customer relations and responsiveness. Conversely, others praise the personal connection they find with the owner, describing face-to-face engagement and fair rates that speak to the value on offer.
Emotionally, Bahney House Hotel evokes a sense of resilience and renewal. From its modest beginnings to its current state of renewed investment, this hotel embodies more than just a place to stay—it tells a story of community and perseverance. For those who appreciate authenticity and the steady progress of a local enterprise, Bahney House offers more than just lodging; it offers a glimpse into Myerstown’s character and spirit.
In sum, Bahney House Hotel is a multifaceted destination. It blends modern conveniences with a rich history and a community-focused outlook. While not perfect, its ongoing evolution and dedication to serving travelers make it a noteworthy choice for visitors seeking a meaningful stay in Pennsylvania’s heartland.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Lot of transiants. Manager (Charlie Klein or Kline) claims to be Christian but threw out Myself and my son on day of My Veteran Husband's Funeral. Leaving us homeless for weeks. His brother John is a Saint. Don't rent from Charlie if you can help it. He will throw you out with no notice.
This place is great for long extended stays the owner will interact with you on a face to face basis rates can't be beat for the room size and amenities like microwave, mini fridge, cable tv, and Wi-Fi. Also a laundry mat is located on the property. Soon there will be a salon located on the property also. Support local businesses they are the back bone of the American dream
I remember this place when I was a kid... It was a pretty crappy place on and off... Looks pretty amazing right now... I'm glad to see someone has invested time in this place as it's been around for a long time.
I took a friend to get her hair done at the salon. They were so kind and accommodating. The building was beautiful. I wish I could have seen more.
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Pennsylvania. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
1,591 reviews 100 Museum Rd, Stevens, PA 17578, United States
1,223 reviews 465 Speedwell Forge Rd, Lititz, PA 17543, United States
65 reviews Appalachian Trl, Pine Grove, PA 17963, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Raintree Inn & Suites offers spacious, quiet rooms with free WiFi, parking, and thoughtful service near San Antonio’s Missions Na...
Mini Golden Inns Motel in Hungry Horse, MT offers clean, remodeled rooms with kitchens, free WiFi, and petfriendly comfort. Just...
Discover The Lazy Ass Ranch, a 4.7star peaceful getaway in Panguitch, UT. Enjoy rustic comfort, free WiFi, and breathtaking view...
Wenton Motel in Saugerties, NY offers clean, airconditioned rooms with kitchens, free WiFi, and parking. Enjoy easy access to hi...
Comanche Motel offers a secure, wellguarded environment ideal for business travelers and visitors exploring Comanche, OK. Enjoy e...
Discover the welcoming charm of Old Saratoga Inn, a toprated motel offering clean rooms, kidfriendly amenities, and exceptional ...
Experience the charm of Little Bear Cabin in Ruidoso, NM. This spacious, spotless cabin offers bearthemed décor, a relaxing hot t...
Discover Lodge House Inn The, a welcoming 3.2star hotel in Avenal, California. Enjoy large rooms with vintage charm, free WiFi, ...
Experience warm hospitality and convenient business amenities at Picayune Motel, located on Hwy 11 N. Ideal for travelers seeking ...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
